How Much Does it Cost to Replace Eavestroughs

There may come a time during homeownership when replacing your gutter system becomes necessary. While it’s not something you need to do often, it’s essential to plan and budget accordingly, especially because this process can come at high prices. So, how much does it actually cost to replace eavestroughs? This answer depends on various factors, like the material you choose, the size of your home, and the contractor you hire. Let’s break down the details to help you understand the costs involved: 

What is an Eavestrough Replacement?

Eavestrough replacement involves removing old, damaged gutters and installing new ones in their place. This replacement process typically involves inspecting the existing eavestroughs, removing any debris or obstructions, and measuring and cutting the new gutters to fit the roofline. The new material is usually attached to your roof using hangers and secured with screws or nails.

Why Eavestrough Replacement is Important

Your gutter plays an important role in protecting your home. It’s designed to catch rainwater from your roof and funnel it away from your property and its foundation. Eavestroughs that are old or broken can pose a threat because of their inability to drain water properly. As a result, you may experience damage to the structure or even find water damage inside your home.

When Do You Need to Replace Eavestroughs?

Eavestrough replacement is a necessary home maintenance task that can prevent costly repairs down the road to your home’s foundation, walls, and roof. In most cases, you can repair the gutter system a few times before you need a full replacement. Here are some of the most common reasons that indicate it’s time for a new one:

  • The eavestrough is consistently overflowing — this indicates that it’s draining improperly.
  • Rust has formed inside the eavestrough, making it more prone to leaks and other damage.
  • There are holes in the eavestrough that have developed due to wear and tear, impact damage, or other factors.
  • There are numerous loose nails, screws, or hangers, causing sections of the eavestrough to detach from the roofline, creating gaps that allow water to seep into your home’s structural elements.
  • The eavestrough is covered in mould — this can be a sign of water damage and may require a full replacement.
  • The paint is severely faded. This may indicate that it’s past its lifespan.
  • Sections are hanging off the roof. This could happen due to improper installation, severe weather impact, or simply age. No matter the cause, a dislodged eavestrough will not drain water adequately.

How Much Does it Cost to Replace Eavestroughs?

Overall, the average homeowner spends between $2,500 and $3,500 for a new gutter system. This price can increase greatly depending on the style of your home and the materials you choose. Let’s take a look at some of these factors in more detail: 


The main factor that impacts the overall cost of replacement is the type of material used. Aluminum and vinyl, for example, are common materials that are relatively inexpensive, while copper and stainless steel are more expensive:

  • Vinyl: Can range from $4 to $8 per linear foot
  • Aluminum: Can range from $6 to $12 per linear foot
  • Stainless steel: Can range from $11 to $30 per linear foot
  • Copper: Can range from $40 to $100 per linear foot

Keep in mind that these ranges are estimates and are subject to change depending on the contractor and market prices for roofing materials.


The cost of labour makes up another large portion of your eavestrough replacement. It depends on the roofing company and the complexity of the job. Generally, you might be looking at around $1 to $12 per linear foot for professional labour or $50 to $70 per hour.


When adding new gutters, old ones usually need to be replaced. This can be done as a DIY project, potentially saving you money. However, disposing of these parts can be challenging, which is why some organizations will include disposable charges, ranging from $100 to $300, depending on the size of the job. It’s also important to note that removing gutters can be dangerous if you don’t have the experience or proper equipment, so it’s safer to leave this kind of work to experienced gutter replacement professionals. 

Other Factors

Here are other considerations to take into account when budgeting for an eavestrough replacement:

  • Size of your home: The more surface area your roof covers, the more eavestrough material is needed.
  • Screens or other add-ons: To make your gutter system more efficient, you may opt for screens or other add-ons, which will increase your overall cost.

More considerations that can increase the total cost include the pitch of the roof (a high-pitched roof comes with a premium), the number of storeys (more than one takes more time and materials), and if you need new downspouts on top of the eavestrough installation. 

Add-Ons for Eavestroughs

As mentioned above, other items, services, and features can be added to make your gutter system more efficient and functional. These add-ons include the following: 

A Redesigned Drainage System

If your current home has an eavestrough with a problematic system, such as improper grading or inadequate drainage, then it may be better to redesign the system altogether. This can involve repositioning downspouts or adding new drainage components. Keep in mind that you’ll likely have to pay more for gutter installation if you do this. 

Gutter Guards

These are effective at eliminating the need to clean your gutters frequently, ultimately saving you money and time. Gutter guards come in various styles, including mesh screens and solid covers, and can be installed on top of your existing gutter. Guards also reduce the risk of unwanted repairs by preventing debris buildups and clogs.

Downspout Screens

These are similar to gutter guards but are specifically designed to fit over the opening of downspouts. These screens help prevent your downspouts from clogging and improve the performance of gutter guards. This add-on diverts dirt away and ensures that water flows smoothly. 

Heat Tape

In Ontario, harsh winter weather can cause ice buildup on the inside or on top of your gutters. Heat tape can be helpful during the winter as it can stop ice from forming in the first place. It’s essentially a thin electrical heating element that goes on the roof edge or inside the gutter. However, this add-on can be expensive and may increase the cost of your eavestrough replacement.

DIY vs. Professional Contractors

To save money, you might consider going the DIY route to cut down on labour costs. This is only advisable if you have experience working in roofing installation. Although eavestrough installation appears to be an easy task that you can do on your own, it can be complex and dangerous without the right expertise and tools.

To install a gutter system on your own, you need to consider the perfect angle that will allow the water to flow down the downspouts. You’ll also need to fasten the material with the right equipment. If eavestroughs are improperly installed, you could seriously damage your roof, which could also lead to water damage, costing you more money than planned.

Due to the risks of DIY replacement, it’s always best to put your trust in a professional when installing the eavestroughs onto your home.

Final Considerations

There are also other factors that will contribute to the amount you pay when installing a gutter, such as location and the level of risk involved. The location of a drain will generally depend on the roof’s design, as some may be in areas that are difficult to reach. 

Removing gutters, especially in old homes, can lead to other damages and repairs if you’re not careful or experienced. It is also important to have a timeline of when the project will be completed. In some instances, companies will charge extra if they are hired to work in inclement weather.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I Need to Install a Drainage System? 

Every property needs a drainage system to help maintain it. Without it, water will collect near the building’s foundation, resulting in the formation of cracks. In some cases, landscapes can become visually unpleasing or possibly unstable due to erosion. Gutters and drainage systems are effective ways to protect your home and property from water-based damage, and they are cost-effective solutions that last for several years. 

How Do I Select the Right Size of Gutter? 

Typically, a gutter will come in two shapes: half-rounds or K-style channels. Additionally, there are three standard sizes: size four is the smallest, five holds approximately 1.5 gallons, and size six holds about two gallons. Choosing the right size depends on your roof’s slope and the rainfall your region receives. 

What is the Lifespan of a Gutter? 

The lifetime of this system will depend on the material used to design it and whether it was installed correctly. For example, gutters made from steel will last around 20 years, while copper will remain in ideal condition for as long as 50 years. In addition, weather conditions and maintenance contribute to your gutter system’s longevity. 

Do I need to replace my gutters if they’re leaking?

It depends on the extent of the damage. If the leak is caused by a small hole or crack, it can usually be repaired. However, replacement is likely necessary if the gutters are severely rusted or damaged.

How often should I clean my gutters?

Gutters should be cleaned at least twice a year, typically in the spring and fall. However, if your home is surrounded by trees or experiences heavy rainfall, more frequent cleanings may be necessary to prevent clogs and maintain proper water flow.

Trust the Professionals at Roofmaster

Are you looking for an affordable and professional option to replace your eavestrough? Our experts at Roofmaster are happy to work closely with you, offering advice and insights to help you choose the best option for your needs. Our design team can also show you all available choices and provide a detailed quote so you can budget accordingly. Contact us today to get started!